Wisconsin Pure Sources Board says no to regulating PFAS in groundwater | WUWM 89.7 FM

Folks involved concerning the public well being dangers posed by PFAS confronted disappointment after a Wisconsin Pure Sources Board vote Wednesday.

The board authorised some limits on two of probably the most studied perpetually chemical substances, however motion fell far wanting what the Division of Pure Sources and residents with contaminated wells have been pushing for.

February 23 was a date individuals like Cindy Boyle have been eagerly ready for the Pure Sources Board to think about proposed PFAS requirements. They’ve been in improvement for over two years.

Residents of Boyle’s City of Peshtigo and neighboring Marinette have been grappling with contaminated wells since they discovered PFAS from a close-by firefighting foam manufacturing and the testing facility had tainted their groundwater.

Cindy Boyle says she’s been preventing for PFAS rules for over 4 years. Her willpower motivated her to run for and develop into the City of Peshtigo’s chairperson.

“For 4 and a half years, I’ve been preventing each single day to set PFOA and PFOS requirements. We’re all on ingesting wells within the city of Peshtigo — 4,000 individuals. One third of our parcels are impacted. [PFAS] proceed emigrate. If we don’t have state requirements, there may be nothing we will do,” Boyle stated.

A rising variety of Wisconsin communities are coping with wells contaminated with the perpetually chemical substances. PFAS are known as that as a result of they don’t break down, and so they accumulate within the our bodies of individuals and wildlife.

Presently, the federal Environmental Safety Company has a lifetime ingesting water well being advisory of 70 components per trillion for 2 of probably the most studied PFAS.

However individuals like Boyle desire a a lot decrease restrict.

The Wisconsin DNR conferred with the state Division of Well being Providers to formulate a proposed 20 components per trillion normal for ingesting water and groundwater. As for floor water, the company floated eight components per trillion restrict.

The Pure Sources Board took testimony, on and debated, all three requirements Wednesday.

Wausau Mayor Katie Rosenberg informed the board the state wants strict requirements. She stated her group doesn’t know the place to show.

“Initially of this 12 months, the Metropolis of Wausau voluntarily examined for PFAS as a result of a neighboring group discovered that one among their wells exceeded each the DNR and the EPA well being advisories. And it’s the fitting factor to do. After we obtained our outcomes, we discovered whereas we’re beneath the EPA advisory, each one among our six wells exceeds the DNR and DHS advisory,” Rosenberg stated. “I’ve pleaded with our companions at state and federal governments to information assist us by means of this.”

However longtime Pure Sources Board member Dr. Fred Prehn challenged Rosenberg. He’s a Wausau resident, and he berated the mayor and native authorities, saying they have been creating hysteria in the neighborhood.

“You need an instantaneous repair that’s been round for generations at the least my era, and there shall be fixes in place. However the truth that you set the City of Wausau in hysteria is unacceptable to me, and that’s precisely what’s happening up there. I hope the individuals of Wausau perceive that’s being handled in a systemic, considerate, authorized method,” Prehn stated.

Scott Manley with Wisconsin Producers & Commerce argued that the DNR overstepped its authority in crafting the proposed requirements.

“Though we imagine there are quite a few authorized issues with the three guidelines, I wish to focus my feedback on two particular deadly flaws with the principles. The primary being the DNR’s failure to observe the rulemaking necessities and the second the illegal use of mixed requirements,” Manley stated.

Screen Shot 2022-02-23 at 1.47.11 PM.png

Pure Sources Board members, together with Invoice Bruins (left) and Tery Hilgenberg, raised considerations concerning the advisable PFAS requirements.

Some Pure Sources Board members raised their very own considerations when voting on the three units of requirements, together with Invoice Bruins.

“All of us need clear water. What divides us right here as we speak is what normal, the place ought to that degree be set to verify it’s secure and clear. To poo EPA suggestions as we speak as a result of they don’t know what they’re doing, they’re outdated. We’ve obtained newer info. EPA has at all times been the gold normal,” Bruins stated.

Sharon Adams, latest to the board, spoke publicly for the primary time. She urged her colleagues to carry on to the proposed 20 components per trillion restrict for ingesting water. The DNR advisable it, citing research exhibiting infants and younger youngsters are significantly susceptible to those PFAs.

Screen Shot 2022-02-24 at 9.12.21 AM.png

Sharon Adams is the latest Pure Sources Board member. She urged her colleagues to stick to the DNR’s suggestions on PFAS requirements.

“I’m troubled by poo pooing 20 as a result of our well being officers, our employees have stood and given us a course of that has integrity. We heard that the goal now are infants and younger youngsters and I’d not dismiss it. I believe it’s vital to face by it,” Adams stated.

After hours of testimony and debate, the Pure Sources Board authorised some limits, however fell wanting the DNR’s suggestions. The board handed the floor water measure with out revision, however tabled the groundwater measure. And it handed a ingesting water normal of 70 components per trillion as an alternative of the a lot decrease proposed restrict of 20 components per trillion.

The group Wisconsin Conservation Voters issued a news release saying it’ll proceed to raise the problem of PFAs and clear water throughout the state.

Have an environmental query you would like WUWM’s Susan Bence to research? Submit beneath.

window.fbAsyncInit = function()

appId : ‘4095511677171674’,

xfbml : true,
version : ‘v2.9’

(function(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(document, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: